-----BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE-----
Hash: SHA256

On Mon, 2025-07-21 at 18:42 +0200, Yves-Alexis Perez wrote:

If both should be in trixie I would say:

Package: strongswan
Depends: charon-systemd | strongswan-charon, strongswan-swanctl

Ah, good point, that might work, let's try that. I'll report back here.

So, it seems to work on Bookworm -> Trixie but won't that mean we'll have the same problem again (for those installs) in Trixie -> Forky if I remove the alternate dependency at that point?

Regards,
- --
Yves-Alexis
-----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE-----

iQEzBAEBCAAdFiEE8vi34Qgfo83x35gF3rYcyPpXRFsFAmh+b9MACgkQ3rYcyPpX RFvZpAgAp/7aHmRrgE0LRChTXxrkv66s6LG8CyTI75XdqLtC23X5HkA+mnRWPwEd TL6FlrqllKkSGeQwHeChisjXA7L8bCDa7Mr+IK2t/JfWcV+suYcmO2zialxJKr2C gBswBp68j5aQj/kfcioCt3ZxE02P0EVTdEFZ5caP/DAYF7GCBfgPA9pgExgb/WB3 ItabU2PHA954kK1dD3+mcjZpn9eMuZB+lYqOzzzTWpAPtjeHo3ZzfNU61jZgYv7L MRBVgvrGAXZefvAMjul8ibDhzJ0ZyasXlCAhQd5/iHH0VITpgv7k7eNKPbk07/cc yzUaoL1qrzusy60u5X8U/F5CseRk0Q==
=dZfo
-----END PGP SIGNATURE-----

--- SoupGate-Win32 v1.05
* Origin: fsxNet Usenet Gateway (21:1/5)

* Yves-Alexis Perez <[email protected]> [2025-07-21 18:50]:

On Mon, 2025-07-21 at 18:42 +0200, Yves-Alexis Perez wrote:

If both should be in trixie I would say:

Package: strongswan
Depends: charon-systemd | strongswan-charon, strongswan-swanctl

Ah, good point, that might work, let's try that. I'll report back here.

So, it seems to work on Bookworm -> Trixie but won't that mean we'll have the >same problem again (for those installs) in Trixie -> Forky if I remove the >alternate dependency at that point?

For Forky you would have to do the transition dummy package and
maintainer scripts conversion then.

Cheers Jochen

-----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE-----

iQIzBAEBCgAdFiEEc7KZy9TurdzAF+h6W//cwljmlDMFAmh+cQMACgkQW//cwljm lDPcFQ/+NBUtbY4crkRg3ecbR5x5eAXR2MXFMtKp22A2FZF8p2/FPW+7iReJiZA/ tSQhZ0hQXdHivMNLIRWUDeP3yWEERT7O5cetJOWZxZuK/9RUKimG2ccl//2usAYX nRcONxRYKNL1ynvujPgy5BsZbPb3NbJMQ+TAlFoFa7hMh+m2KH+BjK7TM9gpneSc 2BLAtPoPN2SDRWCNYSug7w0Wo3wk67N8iuOSTBnowNHdzyZLm3zo/uV/8URDZtgz U8F3Fa+tsJ6388SPnTvhEwWcb3CkkX+f6ddzlDlIK6r9DEXAaQesBDPCTL9gvEhA EpJMw2tbJKeceIlPoPGFMBbQucgb3Bkp5YYBQU4VfLC6jPP5x8vVd0CFXS+Vg2DT 4MnQdg/3VHxojrfUQFywHb1xv9qn3I+ZsQYw0WWrKoj5Df2kt7mcz+8pi/zFgO7k 0bSFZqBx3S6PFBJ/+0CilMIRP3dYu5/52Y8TqOqe0HBDMnCNoOO2a27WoFvNVDVb W6hWsr2giVM84n1TYZY7PZuB4/Ls3mbTr2W1J/GhMRYhU/Chy4slKimoFnfC3Dld 41Xk1A1Q6AV4Ab0s4+U2ET1ojSOuxj15kwwBTjJzi+/GaeXtwbFHv9n5BLle6yNM oqzDnXXDhEONKjTWV9lqMbskzldr1w3SmCmxOmcofGtp2+iOuZA=
=aEC/
-----END PGP SIGNATURE-----

--- SoupGate-Win32 v1.05
* Origin: fsxNet Usenet Gateway (21:1/5)

* Yves-Alexis Perez <[email protected]> [2025-07-22 08:04]:

On Mon, 2025-07-21 at 18:55 +0200, Jochen Sprickerhof wrote:

So, it seems to work on Bookworm -> Trixie but won't that mean we'll have >> > the
same problem again (for those installs) in Trixie -> Forky if I remove the >> > alternate dependency at that point?

For Forky you would have to do the transition dummy package and
maintainer scripts conversion then.

Hey Jochen

as already said, that's not an option for us. There's no plan to retire >strongswan-charon (and strongswan-starter) packages.

Why would you drop the alternate dependency in Forky then?

What should happen to users having strongswan and strongswan-charon
installed when upgrading to Forky?

Btw. there is currently a new solver in apt that would remove strongswan-charon and install charon-systemd instead. That will likely
become the default in Forky so it could work without a transition dummy package then.

In any case, I would propose to add the alternate dependency for Trixie
and do do an upload soon as time is running out.

Cheers Jochen

-----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE-----

iQIzBAEBCgAdFiEEc7KZy9TurdzAF+h6W//cwljmlDMFAmh/MxQACgkQW//cwljm lDOtbw//T8zhNCTQrI1qPBMzYslSBcJ4dLGMGPAdvvsaXTjtxWkfZMETHOAg9ulQ xF061tiZAxkhJhw8HXqr5R0rhvYox0Koe/bmFwW1xfBGFMNq9sW8fMpUSnVBHWKK EEEuGCAq+edGJqLmOI9s2beB58XAqJEvzi9ZKxsCUrrPtx+/PEZhdsTcjYE0jycs 44NCfnmSulkgMZuhfNvmKBrLUS0aWP5LrzJACXQYbNuCredkH0zA5i7XmPYv6YY8 ROBRRqZBZfgcaLKApt19dgftio+6RDEE/YaAc/Rj6wKgsu+D8mPYzkzu8P7OvJab Vv6HKCLC3KOCJJeGIr/S4LZfzZQRNsi9Rxs5yAwbwiDoWUic/xYJGKVVrL9OLUgn T2TUQu4U/Yl2LteJZBwBtcAiAn0QgFhF2cfaKjDwGpzdWA827dUETrWAvQhyEtiW y5FbF7j1bxdYPWqeb4ZOsOixLkYzpy0aWfXnLEw6ZbtwjIHwfs5/KUML//uloGnM IeOGD2QYSNKX0eCXNYxFhTEsblIfBIGdkyLr5stikfvBfnOuKPZzrjf90MZhrUvS 2AxbM+IntBAkcTjNWeqZsYjyHPCYyNt5p/J42IHkRveHPDPhzDpwrr6On6FFtFsA CGIOPBoFZ+xq3LuyMOMSgCX1veRFOiPpEA8hEg2/8x7SqS+1sTo=
=ecay
-----END PGP SIGNATURE-----

--- SoupGate-Win32 v1.05
* Origin: fsxNet Usenet Gateway (21:1/5)