• Measuring CMOS Battery charge

    From Dave@21:1/5 to All on Fri Nov 17 07:29:52 2023
    Maybe a silly question but I'd like to know as it's way outside my
    knowledge base... :-)

    On my old (28.5 years) SARPC, a long time ago I moved the CMOS battery
    from the Mobo up into the gutter top side of the second slice.

    I was wondering, did anyone ever write an app that would measure and
    display the state of the CMOS battery, or even if that is possible?

    Thanks
    Dave

    --

    Dave Triffid

    --- SoupGate-Win32 v1.05
    * Origin: fsxNet Usenet Gateway (21:1/5)
  • From Theo@21:1/5 to Dave on Fri Nov 17 10:28:20 2023
    Dave <[email protected]> wrote:
    Maybe a silly question but I'd like to know as it's way outside my
    knowledge base... :-)

    On my old (28.5 years) SARPC, a long time ago I moved the CMOS battery
    from the Mobo up into the gutter top side of the second slice.

    I was wondering, did anyone ever write an app that would measure and
    display the state of the CMOS battery, or even if that is possible?

    There's no sensors on the CMOS battery, so there's no way of reading it. If you can stick a multimeter on it you can measure the terminal voltage which gives you some idea of its state (dead or not), but it won't give you much accuracy about future lifetime.

    Unlike a phone or laptop, there's no 'gas gauge' monitoring hardware to
    measure how much energy has gone out of it, and to add such monitoring to
    such a small battery would end up draining the battery much faster so
    there's no point.

    You could put a digital voltmeter circuit on it so you could read the
    voltage from software, but would need to design it so that it doesn't cause additional drain.

    Theo

    --- SoupGate-Win32 v1.05
    * Origin: fsxNet Usenet Gateway (21:1/5)
  • From Dave@21:1/5 to Theo on Fri Nov 17 21:05:24 2023
    In article <mGp*[email protected]>,
    Theo <[email protected]> wrote:
    Dave <[email protected]> wrote:
    Maybe a silly question but I'd like to know as it's way outside my knowledge base... :-)

    On my old (28.5 years) SARPC, a long time ago I moved the CMOS battery
    from the Mobo up into the gutter top side of the second slice.

    I was wondering, did anyone ever write an app that would measure and display the state of the CMOS battery, or even if that is possible?

    There's no sensors on the CMOS battery, so there's no way of reading it.
    If you can stick a multimeter on it you can measure the terminal
    voltage which gives you some idea of its state (dead or not), but it
    won't give you much accuracy about future lifetime.

    Unlike a phone or laptop, there's no 'gas gauge' monitoring hardware to measure how much energy has gone out of it, and to add such monitoring
    to such a small battery would end up draining the battery much faster so there's no point.

    You could put a digital voltmeter circuit on it so you could read the
    voltage from software, but would need to design it so that it doesn't
    cause additional drain.

    Theo

    Thanks for the info, appreciated.

    I don't use the old SARPC very often these days, but I run it for a while
    at least once week regardless...
    So once a month while the SARPC is ON, I take the lid off and check the rechargeable battery voltage is still okay.

    That's all I really need to know. :-)

    Dave

    --

    Dave Triffid

    --- SoupGate-Win32 v1.05
    * Origin: fsxNet Usenet Gateway (21:1/5)
  • From David Higton@21:1/5 to Dave on Fri Nov 17 22:49:39 2023
    In message <[email protected]>
    Dave <[email protected]> wrote:

    In article <mGp*[email protected]>,
    Theo <[email protected]> wrote:
    Dave <[email protected]> wrote:
    Maybe a silly question but I'd like to know as it's way outside my knowledge base... :-)

    On my old (28.5 years) SARPC, a long time ago I moved the CMOS battery from the Mobo up into the gutter top side of the second slice.

    I was wondering, did anyone ever write an app that would measure and display the state of the CMOS battery, or even if that is possible?

    There's no sensors on the CMOS battery, so there's no way of reading it.
    If you can stick a multimeter on it you can measure the terminal voltage which gives you some idea of its state (dead or not), but it won't give
    you much accuracy about future lifetime.

    Unlike a phone or laptop, there's no 'gas gauge' monitoring hardware to measure how much energy has gone out of it, and to add such monitoring to such a small battery would end up draining the battery much faster so there's no point.

    You could put a digital voltmeter circuit on it so you could read the voltage from software, but would need to design it so that it doesn't
    cause additional drain.

    Theo

    Thanks for the info, appreciated.

    I don't use the old SARPC very often these days, but I run it for a while
    at least once week regardless... So once a month while the SARPC is ON, I take the lid off and check the rechargeable battery voltage is still okay.

    That's all I really need to know. :-)

    The only problem that you /might/ have is that once a month may or may
    not be enough to make up for the discharge during the rest of the time.
    It's not easy to calculate whether x minutes of use every y days is or
    is not enough - and in any case you probably don't use it on a fully predictable cycle.

    In the end, all it means is that, if one day it doesn't boot up with
    the correct settings, keep it powered on for a good few hours to charge
    the battery up again.

    Also, you may find it more useful to check the battery's voltage before
    you switch on, rather than after, while it's charging.

    David

    --- SoupGate-Win32 v1.05
    * Origin: fsxNet Usenet Gateway (21:1/5)
  • From Dave@21:1/5 to David Higton on Sat Nov 18 15:41:46 2023
    In article <5463f2045b.DaveMeUK@BeagleBoard-xM>,
    David Higton <[email protected]> wrote:
    In message <[email protected]>
    Dave <[email protected]> wrote:

    [Snip]

    Thanks for the info, appreciated.

    I don't use the old SARPC very often these days, but I run it for a
    while at least once week regardless... So once a month while the SARPC
    is ON, I take the lid off and check the rechargeable battery voltage
    is still okay.

    That's all I really need to know. :-)

    The only problem that you /might/ have is that once a month may or may
    not be enough to make up for the discharge during the rest of the time.
    It's not easy to calculate whether x minutes of use every y days is or
    is not enough - and in any case you probably don't use it on a fully predictable cycle.

    In the end, all it means is that, if one day it doesn't boot up with
    the correct settings, keep it powered on for a good few hours to charge
    the battery up again.

    Also, you may find it more useful to check the battery's voltage before
    you switch on, rather than after, while it's charging.

    David

    Generally good advice...

    In my case, the running once a week is usually for at least four hours.

    I usually test the voltage before starting the computer to get a truer
    battery reading.
    But then occasionally once the computer *is running* I take the battery
    out of its holder and test it, and if it's showing signs of being a bit
    low, I temporarily put another battery in the holder, then take the rechargeable elsewhere to put it on charge for much longer.

    Then when charged up, putting it back inside the (Obviously running)
    computer.

    I've been doing this for many years (15) and not *yet* lost any CMOS
    settings.

    Which is more than can be said about the number of times the VRPC CMOS has
    gone crapola. :-)

    No biggy of course, as any long time user of Virtual Acorns knows, keep
    regular backups of the CMOS file. :-)

    Dave

    --

    Dave Triffid

    --- SoupGate-Win32 v1.05
    * Origin: fsxNet Usenet Gateway (21:1/5)
  • From David Higton@21:1/5 to Dave on Sat Nov 18 20:31:07 2023
    In message <[email protected]>
    Dave <[email protected]> wrote:

    In my case, the running once a week is usually for at least four hours.

    I usually test the voltage before starting the computer to get a truer battery reading. But then occasionally once the computer *is running* I
    take the battery out of its holder and test it, and if it's showing signs
    of being a bit low, I temporarily put another battery in the holder, then take the rechargeable elsewhere to put it on charge for much longer.

    Then when charged up, putting it back inside the (Obviously running) computer.

    I've been doing this for many years (15) and not *yet* lost any CMOS settings.

    Which is more than can be said about the number of times the VRPC CMOS has gone crapola. :-)

    No biggy of course, as any long time user of Virtual Acorns knows, keep regular backups of the CMOS file. :-)

    Clearly you have a good system in place!

    David

    --- SoupGate-Win32 v1.05
    * Origin: fsxNet Usenet Gateway (21:1/5)