1. Forum
  2. FidoNet
  3. FIDONET.TELEGRAM

  • msgid bug when cc?

    From August Abolins@2:221/1.58 to Stas Mishchenkov on Mon Dec 21 08:58:00 2020
    Hello Stas! @BroRabbit

    I posted a message to CHAT, with a //CC to ASIAN_LINK. The
    resultant messages had the same MSGID:

    Newsgroups: chat
    Subject: Back to the BBS - The return to being online (Part One)
    Date: Sun, 20 Dec 2020 23:32:14
    Message-ID: <350$chat@SmapiNNTPd>
    X-SMAPI-From: August Abolins
    X-SMAPI-To: All
    X-SMAPI-DateWritten: 20 Dec 20 23:32:14
    X-SMAPI-DateArrived: 20 Dec 20 22:33:50
    X-SMAPI-Control: @MSGID: 2:460/58 000000a2
    X-SMAPI-Control: @PID: tg_BBS_v0.6.3

    EMP: /FIDO/ASIAN_LINK
    ABS: August Abolins@2:460/58
    BET: Back to the BBS - The return to being online (Part One)
    ROT: 2:221/1!460/58 280/464 221/1
    MID: 2:460/58 000000a2
    EDA: 20201220233200W+0
    LEN: 190
    MAILER: tg_BBS_v0.6.3 / tg BBS v0.6.3


    Shouldn't the MSGID's be unique per AREA, or unique per
    Mailer/BBS?

    The reason I'm asking this is because my OpenXP system is
    configured to carry both echos and it tests for dupes, and it
    decided to delete the one that was destined for CHAT. As a
    result, my system only has one of the above messages


    --
    ../|ug

    --- OpenXP 5.0.47
    * Origin: Mobile? https://t.me/joinchat/SPBwvE1gkHzEKAkapsHkdQ (2:221/1.58)
  • From Wilfred van Velzen@2:280/464 to August Abolins on Mon Dec 21 15:09:54 2020
    Hi August,

    On 2020-12-21 08:58:00, you wrote to Stas Mishchenkov:

    Shouldn't the MSGID's be unique per AREA, or unique per
    Mailer/BBS?

    http://ftsc.org/docs/fts-0009.001 is clear about that: "and a serial number unique to that message on the originating system"

    The reason I'm asking this is because my OpenXP system is
    configured to carry both echos and it tests for dupes, and it
    decided to delete the one that was destined for CHAT. As a
    result, my system only has one of the above messages

    OpenXP is behaving correctly...

    Bye, Wilfred.

    --- FMail-lnx64 2.1.0.18-B20170815
    * Origin: FMail development HQ (2:280/464)
  • From Stas Mishchenkov@2:460/5858 to August Abolins on Mon Dec 21 19:12:14 2020
    Hi, August!

    21 ��� 20 08:58, August Abolins -> Stas Mishchenkov:

    I posted a message to CHAT, with a //CC to ASIAN_LINK. The
    resultant messages had the same MSGID:

    Newsgroups: chat

    X-SMAPI-Control: @MSGID: 2:460/58 000000a2

    EMP: /FIDO/ASIAN_LINK
    MID: 2:460/58 000000a2

    Shouldn't the MSGID's be unique per AREA, or unique per
    Mailer/BBS?

    The reason I'm asking this is because my OpenXP system is
    configured to carry both echos and it tests for dupes, and it
    decided to delete the one that was destined for CHAT. As a
    result, my system only has one of the above messages

    Strictly speaking, this is a violation of the standard. In the near future this procedure will be completely rewritten.

    Have nice nights.
    Stas Mishchenkov.

    --- - � �� �� ��樮���쭮��...? - ����-��. � ��? - ���. - � � ⠪?
    * Origin: Lame Users Breeding. Simferopol, Crimea. (2:460/5858)